HOA may require removal of festive decor
An HOA member reported that the association requested the removal of holiday decorations from the homeowner’s property and threatened a fine for non‑compliance. The homeowner is unsure whether the HOA has legal authority to enforce such a demand.
HOAs operate under governing documents, such as Covenants, Conditions, and Restrictions (CC&Rs) and bylaws, which often outline permissible exterior decorations, timing, and size limits. If the homeowner’s display conflicts with these provisions, the HOA may rightfully require removal and impose penalties.
The homeowner should first review the governing documents to confirm whether a holiday decoration rule exists. Documentation of all communications—including letters, emails, and notices—along with photographs of the decorations provides evidence for any dispute.
If the rule appears unclear or unevenly enforced, the homeowner can discuss the matter directly with the board or property‑management company, requesting clarification. Should the HOA remain firm, collective action is an option: neighbors can petition the board to revise the rule or the homeowner may seek a board position to influence future decisions.
These steps illustrate the balance between individual preference and community standards that homeowners must navigate within a homeowners’ association. Gary Singer, a board‑certified real estate lawyer, is available for questions at gary@garysingerlaw.com.